For anything Judges Guild: Judges Guild Booty List

For Break in at Three Kilometer Island you might get $2-3

ShaneG.

Mars wrote in Some Obscure Super-Hero RPG Books - Gauging rarity:Probably the one that holds the most value is the TSR Marvel Super Heroes because it was the most produced and widely available so more people were exposed to it and collect it now.

I'd say they're more likely to sell due to familiarity/interest, but they're also pretty widely available, so I wouldn't expect them to bring a lot.  They're freely available (I'm unclear on the legal status) as pdfs too.

I don't know a ton about hero games, but the only main line items I recall seeing bringing decent money are Villains & Vigilantes 1E and Wings Of The Valkyrie (for Champions).

Golden Heros can be found maily in the UK, faily uncommon in the USA.. sometimes people want to buy from USA as shipping internationally (ie UK to USA) is quite a bit expensive

Brette:)

The rarest Super Hero RPG should be Vindicators (only rulebook and one supplement). I didn't see it for sale more than twice.

Yes, Vindicators plus. I don't know if Northridge Games did another game or supplement for another game. (vindicators does not mention Northridge Games, only the supplement)

OK, so apparently the item to beat, which topped both my Horror on the Orient Express AND my Cthulhu Deities and Demigods, is indeed TSR's Marvel SAGA, as long as it has the 96 FATE cards intact (regardless of whether or not it has the 4 additional promo cards).

The auction I did went to $81.

Which, well I guess it's TSR so it belongs in the other forum, but let's be honest: when you think TSR, you think D&D, and then maybe something else, then maybe Marvel, and even then not SAGA.

Next up was Villains and Vigilantes (plus some other V&V books and some non-rare JG stuff), as it had some errata printings that are apparently obscure ($57).  Who knew?

The Golden Heroes RPG items didn't go as high as Completed Listings made me think they would, but at over $5 each, they do make me slightly regret not separating some auctions out.

I probably could have separated out the Champions and Feng Shui and nickle-n-dimed them, but that was more work than I wanted, so someone might have got a deal there.  Definitely someone won big with the Sailor Moon RPG (plus Silver Age Sentinels and the Authority sourcebook) for less than $10.

Didn't expect an older Mutants & Masterminds rulebook to get more than $5, but it did make less than $10...

That's about all that was notable to report.  Cairo Guidebook went for a little over cost ($20.50), so that was good considering I ruined the last couple pages when I first got it (100% documented on the auction!)

Surprising... The last ones still sold for more than $100 (way lower than before kickstarter of course)